Win rate, profit factor and expectancy: what each one tells you

The numbers every trading journal should track, how to calculate them, and why you need to read them together instead of trusting any one.

The short version

MetricThe question it answersHow it is calculated
Win rateHow often do I win?Winning trades / all trades
Average win and average lossHow big are my wins and losses?Total of wins / number of wins, and the same for losses
Payoff ratioAre my wins bigger than my losses?Average win / average loss
Profit factorHow much do I make per unit I lose?Gross profit / gross loss
ExpectancyWhat does one trade earn on average?Win rate x average win, minus loss rate x average loss
R multipleHow did the trade do versus what I risked?Profit or loss / amount risked
Max drawdownHow deep was my worst losing stretch?Biggest fall from a peak to the next low

No single number is enough. Win rate alone can look great while you lose money, and profit factor alone can come from three lucky trades. Read them together.

Win rate

Win rate is the share of trades that closed in profit. A 60% win rate sounds good, but it says nothing about how much you win or lose when you are right or wrong. A trader who wins small and loses big can win 8 trades in 10 and still go broke.

Average win, average loss and payoff ratio

Divide your average win by your average loss to get the payoff ratio. It decides how often you need to win to break even: the break-even win rate is 1 / (1 + payoff ratio).

Payoff ratioWin rate needed to break even
0.5 (wins half the size of losses)66.7%
1.050.0%
2.0 (wins twice the size of losses)33.3%
3.025.0%

Profit factor

Profit factor is gross profit divided by gross loss. Above 1.00 you made more than you lost, and 1.00 is break-even. If you made $2,000 on winning trades and lost $1,000 on losing ones, your profit factor is 2.00. It is only as reliable as the number of trades behind it: a profit factor of 3 over eight trades means very little.

Expectancy

Expectancy is the average result of one trade. The formula is win rate x average win minus loss rate x average loss. A positive number means your approach has earned money per trade so far, and multiplying it by your trades per month gives a rough sense of scale. It is the single most useful number here because it combines win rate and trade size.

A worked example: why win rate misleads

Two traders each take 100 trades.

Trader ATrader B
Win rate80%40%
Average win$10$60
Average loss$60$30
Payoff ratio0.172.00
Profit factor0.671.33
Expectancy per trade-$4.00+$6.00
Result over 100 trades-$400+$600

Trader A wins four trades in five and still loses money, because the losses are six times the size of the wins. Trader B loses more often than not and makes money. Looking at win rate alone, you would pick the wrong trader.

R multiples

If you decide before a trade how much you will risk (your stop loss distance times size), you can express the result as a multiple of that risk. Making $90 on a trade that risked $40 is +2.25R, and a full stop-out is -1R. Averaging R multiples lets you compare trades of different sizes and instruments, and the average R is your expectancy in R. The free template calculates this when you fill in the risk column.

Max drawdown

Max drawdown is the largest fall from a peak to the next low, in money or percent. It shows how bad the bad stretches get, which tells you whether you could actually stay with your approach through one. Recovery is also lopsided: after a 50% loss you need a 100% gain to get back to even.

How many trades do you need?

Metrics from a handful of trades are mostly noise. As rough rules of thumb, treat under about 30 trades as a hint, and look for 100 or more before trusting a pattern. Keep conditions comparable too: one strategy, one market type, and the same rules.

Where to get these numbers

Once you have the numbers, the weekly trading review checklist shows how to turn them into one change for next week. If you are still deciding how to collect the trades, see how to track MT5 trades automatically.

This guide explains record keeping and statistics. It is not trading or investment advice.

R multiples in a table (hypothetical)

Suppose you risk $50 on every trade. Each result converts to R by dividing by 50:

TradeResult ($)Result in R
1+100+2.00R
2-50-1.00R
3+75+1.50R
4-50-1.00R
5-50-1.00R
6+150+3.00R
7-50-1.00R
8+25+0.50R

The average of the eight results is +0.375R, which is the expectancy in R. A positive average R over a large sample means the approach has earned money relative to what it risked; over eight trades it is only an illustration.

How the metrics relate

Common calculation errors

MistakeEffectFix
Using gross profit instead of netEverything looks better than it isAdd commission and swap to each trade
Counting deals instead of positionsWin rate and trade count are wrongCount closed positions
Including deposits and withdrawalsProfit and drawdown are distortedRemove balance rows
Mixing demo and liveMeaningless statisticsCalculate each separately
Averaging percentages across different balancesMisleading averageCalculate from the compounded balance, or use R

Which metric to look at when

You want to knowLook at
Whether the approach pays on averageExpectancy (in R or money)
Whether wins are big enoughPayoff ratio and break-even win rate
Whether it is robust or luckyProfit factor and the number of trades behind it
Whether you can live with itMax drawdown and longest losing streak
Where to improveSlice by setup, session and plan followed

Try your own figures in the expectancy calculator and the losing streak calculator, and see MT5 trading statistics for a full ten-trade worked example.

Related guides

Have these calculated from your real MT5 trades

Free for 7 days, no card required. After that, a one-time $19.99 purchase. No subscription. Also on the Microsoft Store.

One-time $19.99, no monthly fee · your MT5 login never leaves your PC · trades go into your own journal on your PC, not through our servers.

Start free 7-day trial