Position size changes in MT5 history: how consistent was your sizing?

See whether size drift, not the setup, decided your month, and how to compare trades of different sizes.

Position size is the quiet variable in most trading histories. Two traders can take identical setups and finish a month very differently simply because one varied the lot size from trade to trade. MetaTrader 5 records the volume of every position, so you can see how consistent your sizing really was. This page shows how to read the Volume column, how to spot size drift after wins and losses, and how to compare results fairly when sizes were not constant.

Where size lives in the history

In the Positions view, the Volume column holds the size of each position in lots. In the Deals view you see the volume of each entry and exit deal, and a partially closed position produces several exit deals whose volumes add up to the entry; see partial closes in history and scaling in and out. A lot is a different amount for different instruments, which is why the same number can mean very different money; read lot size and contract size explained, and check the minimum and step for your symbol in lot step and minimum volume.

What size drift looks like

Drift means your size changes for reasons unrelated to the setup. Common patterns include sizing up after a winning streak because things feel easy, sizing up after a loss to get back to even, and sizing down after a bad run out of fear. None of these is a crime, but they change the shape of your results. If your largest losses cluster on your largest sizes, the loss was caused as much by the size decision as by the trade. Spot the pattern by listing positions in time order with their volume and net result side by side.

Pattern in the listWhat it may suggestWhere to look next
Size rises after a winConfidence creeping into sizingNotes on the following trades
Size rises after a lossAn urge to recover the lossRevenge trading checklist
Size falls after a lossFear or cautionWhether good setups were skipped
One very large sizeA one-off conviction tradeWhether the plan allowed it
Stable sizeA consistent sizing ruleWhether the rule fits the account

Comparing results when size varied

Raw profit mixes the quality of the trade with the size you chose. To separate them, compute a result per lot for each position: net result divided by volume. A position that earned 30.00 on 0.30 lots and one that earned 10.00 on 0.10 lots performed identically per lot, even though the money differs threefold. Per-lot results make setups comparable across different sizes. Be careful with the arithmetic when the position was closed in several parts, since the volume to divide by is the full entry volume. Costs also scale roughly with size, so use net results throughout.

A worked example (hypothetical)

Invented figures for six consecutive positions on one symbol:

#Volume (lots)Net resultResult per lotPrevious trade
10.10+12.00+120start
20.10+9.00+90win
30.20-26.00-130win
40.30-39.00-130loss
50.10+8.00+80loss
60.10+11.00+110win

Per lot, the six trades are not very different: the two losers cost 130 per lot and the winners earned between 80 and 120. The total money tells a harsher story. Trades 3 and 4 were sized at two and three times the earlier trades, and they lost 65.00 between them, which wiped out the 20.00 of gains from the first two and left the sequence negative even though four of six trades won. The setups were not the problem in this made-up sequence; the size changes were. That is a useful thing to find out, and it is only visible when volume is placed next to result and sequence.

Setting a sizing rule and checking it

A sizing rule can be simple: a fixed lot size, or a fixed fraction of the account risked per trade, converted to lots using your stop distance. Whatever you choose, write it down and then use the history to audit it. Count how many positions fell outside the rule, and look at their results. Do not judge yourself harshly; just collect the evidence. Quick tools for the conversion include the free position size calculator and, for gold, XAUUSD lot size by account size. For the drawdown angle on varying size, see equity versus balance drawdown.

Prop firms and size limits

If you trade under a funded-account programme, its rules may restrict position size or require consistent sizing. Rules differ by firm and change over time, so read the current rules on the firm's own site rather than relying on a summary. The history can help you check your own behaviour against whichever rule applies; see the consistency rule and your journal.

AI Trading Journal is a Windows app for MetaTrader 5 only. It reads closed trades from the terminal on your PC, adds new ones every 5 minutes, and keeps the journal in a file in your Documents folder. Each trade in the journal lists its volume, and the Journal page lets you filter and search, so you can find your largest positions and read the notes you wrote on them. The app is read-only: it never places, modifies or closes a trade, and it gives no trading advice. The 7-day trial needs no card, and the full version is $19.99 once, with no subscription.

Limits

Frequently asked questions

Where do I find position size in MT5 history?
In the Volume column of the Positions view, in lots. Deals show the volume of each entry and exit.
How do I compare trades of different sizes?
Divide each net result by the full entry volume to get a result per lot, and compare those.
What is size drift?
Changing your size for reasons unrelated to the setup, for example after a win or a loss.
How do I audit my own sizing rule?
List positions in time order with volume and result, count those outside your rule and read their results and notes.
Does the app record my intended risk?
No. You can write it in the notes field of each journal entry.

Related guides

Audit your sizing: free for 7 days

Free for 7 days, no card required. After that, a one-time $19.99 purchase. No subscription. Also on the Microsoft Store.

One-time $19.99, no monthly fee · your MT5 login never leaves your PC · trades go into your own journal on your PC, not through our servers.

Start free 7-day trial