MT5 trade history by symbol: how to see which instruments really pay
A fair way to rank instruments from your own history without trusting tiny samples.
Sooner or later every trader asks which instruments actually pay and which quietly drain the account. MetaTrader 5 stores a Symbol on every closed position, so the raw material for the answer is already in your History tab. The hard part is not the sum; it is reading the sum fairly when your broker adds suffixes, when sample sizes differ wildly, and when one oversized trade dominates a symbol. This page shows how to group closed trades by symbol, what to put beside each total, and how to avoid conclusions the data cannot support.
Step one: get one clean name per instrument
The Symbol column shows whatever name your broker uses. Some brokers append a suffix to mark an account type or a feed, so the same market can appear as two or three different strings across accounts or over time. Before grouping, decide on one clean name per instrument and rename the variants in a helper column. The background is in symbol suffixes and broker symbol names. If you skip this step, your best symbol may be split into two half-sized rows that each look unremarkable.
Step two: use positions, not raw deals
Group the Positions view, where each row is one trade from open to close, not the Deals view, where a single trade produces at least two rows. Counting deals doubles the trade count and mixes entry rows, which carry no profit, with exit rows. The distinction is explained in positions versus deals. For each position take Profit, Swap and Commission and add them, because a symbol that looks profitable before costs can be flat after them; see trading costs in your history.
What to calculate for each symbol
| Measure | How to get it | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Trade count | Number of closed positions with that symbol | Tells you how much weight to give the rest |
| Net result | Sum of profit, swap and commission | The bottom line for the symbol |
| Average result | Net result divided by trade count | Puts symbols with different activity on one footing |
| Win rate | Winning positions divided by trade count | Context only; it says nothing about size |
| Largest win and largest loss | Maximum and minimum net result | Shows whether one trade carries the symbol |
| Average holding time | Mean of close time minus open time | Separates scalps from positions held for days |
Resist the urge to rank by net result alone. A symbol traded forty times with a small positive total and a symbol traded three times with a large one are not comparable statements. Show the count in the same row as the result, always.
A worked example (hypothetical)
The figures below are invented to show how to read the table. They do not describe any real market or broker.
| Symbol | Trades | Net result | Average | Largest win | Largest loss |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Symbol A | 42 | +86.00 | +2.05 | +31.00 | -24.00 |
| Symbol B | 27 | -58.00 | -2.15 | +12.00 | -40.00 |
| Symbol C | 3 | +95.00 | +31.67 | +88.00 | -9.00 |
| Symbol D | 11 | -4.00 | -0.36 | +14.00 | -16.00 |
At a glance Symbol C looks like the star. Look closer: three trades, one of which produced 88.00 of the 95.00. Remove that one position and the symbol is roughly flat. Symbol A is the more informative row, because forty-two trades with a modest average and a bounded worst loss say something repeatable about how you handle that market. Symbol B is the row worth a conversation with yourself, though not yet a decision: twenty-seven trades is a small sample, and the cause could be the instrument, the time of day you trade it, or a stretch of poor discipline that happened to fall on it. Cross-check with weekday and hour patterns before blaming the symbol.
Quick ways to build the table
- Copy the Positions rows into a spreadsheet; see sorting, filtering and copying history rows, then build a pivot table with Symbol as rows and net result as values.
- Use a second pivot for the count and a third for the maximum and minimum, then place them side by side.
- Refresh the pivot only for a fixed date range, so last month and this month can be compared like for like.
- Keep a notes column for context, such as a news release or a change in lot size.
Reading the result without fooling yourself
Three traps appear again and again. The first is small samples: with a handful of trades, luck explains almost everything, and the table will happily show you a pattern that disappears next month. The second is concentration: a symbol can owe its entire result to a single trade, as above. The third is mixing contexts: if you traded one symbol during a calm period and another during a volatile one, the comparison says more about the weeks than the instruments. A sensible rule is to treat a symbol as a finding only when it has a reasonable number of trades across more than one period and the result does not vanish when the best trade is removed. What counts as reasonable is your call; the point is to decide before you look.
What to do with it
The review is for understanding, not for dictating changes. Write down one observation per symbol in your own words, and note what you would want to see next month to confirm it. If you keep a journal with setup and emotion fields, filter by symbol and read the notes on the worst trades; a pattern in the notes is more useful than a pattern in the totals. A related view is buy versus sell results, which uses the same grouping idea on direction instead of instrument.
AI Trading Journal is a Windows app for MetaTrader 5 only. It reads closed trades from the terminal on your PC, adds new ones every 5 minutes, and keeps the journal in a file in your Documents folder. The Excel report it exports includes a net P&L by symbol chart on the Summary tab with live formulas, so you do not have to build the pivot yourself, and the Journal page can be filtered by symbol. The app is read-only: it never places, modifies or closes a trade, and it gives no trading advice. The 7-day trial needs no card, and the full version is $19.99 once, with no subscription.
Limits
- Results by symbol say nothing about future results and are not trading advice.
- Open positions are not in the closed history, so a symbol with a large floating loss looks better than it is until it closes.
- Result is in your account currency; for cross-currency details see profit currency versus account currency.
- The journal app does not record intended prices or slippage, so it cannot tell which symbols suffered worse fills.
Frequently asked questions
How do I see which symbol makes the most money in MT5?
Should I count deals or positions?
Why does the same instrument appear twice?
How many trades do I need before trusting a symbol result?
Does the journal app show results by symbol?
Related guides
- A local trading journal for MT5
- P&L calendar for MT5
- Trade notes, ratings and screenshots
- Trading progress and goals
- Back up your journal and move it to a new PC
- An offline trading journal for Windows
- How to set monthly trading goals
- Import your whole MT5 history
- How to tag trades
- Trade screenshots for your journal
- All trading journal comparisons
See results by symbol: free for 7 days
Free for 7 days, no card required. After that, a one-time $19.99 purchase. No subscription. Also on the Microsoft Store.
One-time $19.99, no monthly fee · your MT5 login never leaves your PC · trades go into your own journal on your PC, not through our servers.
Start free 7-day trial