Martingale and grid trades in your MT5 history: what the data shows
The fingerprints these methods leave, why win rate flatters them, and the numbers worth checking instead.
Martingale and grid methods have a loyal following and a bad reputation, and both are easy to run on MetaTrader 5 through an Expert Advisor or by hand. This page does not argue for or against them. It answers a narrower, practical question: what do such methods look like in your trade history, how can you recognise them in your own data, and which numbers in a review show their risk honestly? The aim is for a trader who uses one, or who bought an EA that does, to see what is really happening on the account.
What the two methods are, in plain words
A martingale approach increases the size of the next position after a loss, with the idea that one win will recover the earlier losses. A grid approach places a series of orders at fixed price intervals above and below the market and closes them in groups when price moves a set distance. Real systems combine and vary these ideas in many ways, and the names are used loosely, so this page describes behaviour you can observe rather than a fixed definition.
The fingerprints in a trade history
You do not need the EA’s source code to see the pattern. The History tab shows it in several ways, and a spreadsheet makes it clearer. Open the closed positions, sort by open time, and read down the list.
| Pattern in the history | What it can indicate |
|---|---|
| Lot sizes that step up after losing trades (0.01, 0.02, 0.04, 0.08) | Size increases after losses, a martingale feature |
| Many positions in one symbol, opened at regular price steps | A grid of orders |
| A cluster of positions closed at the same minute | Basket closing, common in grids |
| Long holding times for a few trades and short times for most | Losing positions held while the rest cycle |
| Many small wins and a rare, very large loss | A skewed result shape; see the example below |
On a hedging account every position in a grid appears as its own row; on a netting account the orders merge into one position with an averaged entry, which hides the individual steps. See hedging vs netting and how the average entry price is built for how that merge works.
Why win rate flatters these methods
The usual headline number, the share of winning trades, can be very high for a method that closes many small winners and holds the losers. A review that stops at win rate will not show the weakness. The numbers that matter are the size of the average loss against the average win, the largest single loss, the deepest drop of equity and the time it took to recover. Equity matters most, because the balance line does not include open losing positions while the equity line does. See equity vs balance drawdown and floating vs realized profit.
A worked example (hypothetical)
Suppose an account closed 100 trades in a month. Ninety-two were winners averaging +3.00 each and eight were losers averaging -30.00 each. All the numbers are invented to show the shape.
| Measure | Value |
|---|---|
| Trades | 100 |
| Win rate | 92 percent |
| Total of winners | +276.00 |
| Total of losers | -240.00 |
| Net result | +36.00 |
| Average win / average loss | 3.00 / 30.00 |
| Break-even win rate for this average win and loss | about 91 percent |
A 92 percent win rate sounds excellent, yet the net result is small, and a single extra loss of -40.00 would erase it. The break-even win rate for these averages is about 91 percent, calculated as the average loss divided by the sum of the average win and the average loss. Anyone reading only the win rate would miss that the account is living one bad trade from zero. This is the kind of check a review should always include; for a calculator see the risk-reward calculator and for the related expectancy idea expected payoff explained.
Questions to put to your own history
- What is the largest single loss, and how many typical wins does it take to repay it?
- What was the deepest equity drawdown, and was it before or after a series of increasing lot sizes? See building an equity curve from history.
- How long was the longest period with open losing positions, and what was the margin level at the worst moment? See margin level explained and stop-out and margin call.
- Does the account’s swap cost grow while positions are held? See swap explained.
- How big would the next size step be, and does the balance allow it? Doing this arithmetic in advance, on paper, is a plain form of risk awareness.
What a journal adds for this kind of trading
Automated and semi-automated methods produce plenty of rows and very few notes, so the reasons behind your own decisions get lost: why you switched the EA off, why you increased a setting, why you closed a basket early. AI Trading Journal is a Windows app for MetaTrader 5 only. It reads closed trades from the terminal on your PC and adds new ones every 5 minutes, and it stores the journal in a file in your Documents folder. On the Journal page you can attach a setup, an emotion, a plan-followed flag, a rating, tags and notes to each entry, and the dashboard and P&L calendar show daily, weekly and monthly results. The Progress page can hold a monthly loss limit that you set for yourself. The app is read-only and does not place, modify or close trades, and it does not judge a method; it gives you the record to do that.
Limits and cautions
- Methods that raise size after losses can lose a large amount quickly; this page does not recommend them and is not trading advice.
- A history shows what happened under past conditions only; a calm period can make any method look safe.
- Open positions are not in the closed-trade history, so the worst moments may be missing from it; check equity separately.
- All example numbers are hypothetical.
Frequently asked questions
How do I see whether an EA uses martingale in MT5?
Why is the win rate so high but the profit so small?
Does the balance show the real risk of a grid?
Can the history show the largest drawdown?
Does the journal app warn me about size increases?
Related guides
- A local trading journal for MT5
- P&L calendar for MT5
- Trade notes, ratings and screenshots
- Trading progress and goals
- Back up your journal and move it to a new PC
- An offline trading journal for Windows
- How to set monthly trading goals
- Import your whole MT5 history
- How to tag trades
- Trade screenshots for your journal
- All trading journal comparisons
Keep notes beside every trade: journal free for 7 days
Free for 7 days, no card required. After that, a one-time $19.99 purchase. No subscription. Also on the Microsoft Store.
One-time $19.99, no monthly fee · your MT5 login never leaves your PC · trades go into your own journal on your PC, not through our servers.
Start free 7-day trial