How to reconcile your broker statement with your MT5 trade history
Match the period and clock first, then the balance, the totals and the rows, and find the single row that usually explains the gap.
Your broker sends a statement, your MetaTrader 5 terminal shows a history, and your own journal or spreadsheet holds a third version. Most of the time they agree. When they do not, you lose time hunting for a difference of a few cents, or worse, you stop trusting your own numbers. This page gives a calm, repeatable way to reconcile them: what to line up first, the usual reasons for a mismatch, and what to do when a gap remains.
Know what each document is
The broker’s statement is the official record of the account, produced from the broker’s own system. The terminal History is a view of the same account, filtered by the period and view you chose. A journal or spreadsheet is a copy that you or a tool made from the terminal. Differences usually come from the filters and the conventions, rarely from missing money. Start from the assumption that the statement is right and that your copy has not yet been matched to it.
| Document | Source | Common reason it differs |
|---|---|---|
| Broker statement | Broker back office | Period boundaries, time zone, currency |
| Terminal History | Your terminal, from the server | Period and view setting, hidden rows |
| Journal or spreadsheet | A copy of the History | Copied from a different period or view, duplicated rows |
Match the frame before you match the numbers
- Period. Use the same start and end dates and times in both. A period set to the last three months in the terminal is not the same as calendar quarter; see history period and custom date range.
- Time zone. Terminal times follow the broker’s server clock, while a statement may use another zone. A trade closed just before midnight can fall on different days; see MT5 server time.
- Currency. Totals in the account currency only; a profit currency different from the account currency is converted at the time of closing, see profit currency vs account currency.
- View. Positions, Orders and Deals show different rows for the same activity; see positions vs deals count mismatch.
Reconcile in three layers
Work from the top down and stop when a layer matches, so you do not chase small items before the big ones are settled.
| Layer | Check | If it does not match |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Balance | Starting balance plus every deposit, withdrawal, credit and closed result equals the ending balance | Look for non-trade rows; see balance and deposit rows |
| 2. Totals | Total profit, commission and swap match | Compare each of the three separately; see commission on deals |
| 3. Rows | Each ticket appears once with the same result | Sort both by ticket or position ID and compare lists side by side |
The usual causes of a difference
- A deposit, withdrawal, bonus or correction counted as a trade, or left out of the balance maths.
- A partial close that appears as one position in one place and as several deals in another.
- A rollover (swap) charge posted after midnight server time and falling in the next period.
- Commission charged on both the entry deal and the exit deal, so a position has two cost lines.
- A trade still open at the period end, which is in the terminal Trade tab but not yet in closed history.
- Rounding to two decimals on each row, which can add up to a cent or two across hundreds of rows.
- A duplicated paste in a spreadsheet, or rows that were filtered out and forgotten.
A worked example (hypothetical)
A trader compares a monthly statement with a copy of the terminal History. The statement shows a net trading result of +412.60. The copy adds up to +398.10, a gap of 14.50. Following the layers, the balance row check passes, the totals check fails on swap: the statement has swap of -31.50 while the copy has -17.00. The difference of 14.50 is exactly one overnight charge on a position that was held over a Wednesday and closed on the first day of the next month. The terminal period ended at the last minute of the month, so the closing deal and its swap landed in the next period in the copy. Moving the period end by one day fixed the totals. The numbers are invented, but the pattern, a single row crossing a boundary, is the most common one.
When a small gap remains
If everything matches except a few cents, check rounding by comparing row totals with the statement’s figure and accept a tolerance that you write down, for example one cent per hundred rows. If a gap of a real amount remains after the three layers, do not edit your copy to force it. Keep the statement and the export, note the difference and the ticket numbers involved, and ask the broker’s support to explain the row. Quote the account number, the period and the ticket, and keep the conversation in writing.
Making the check shorter next month
Reconciliation is quick when your own copy is built the same way each month. AI Trading Journal is a Windows app for MetaTrader 5 only. It reads closed trades from the terminal on your PC, keeps one entry per closed position with partial closes combined, dated by the last exit on the broker’s server clock, and the result is profit plus commission plus swap. Knowing that convention in advance explains most day-boundary gaps. Its Export Report to Excel button writes a workbook with Summary, Daily and Trades tabs and live formulas, which gives you a stable copy to compare with the statement. It is read-only and does not replace the broker’s own records. See also MT5 trade history for tax records and saving reports as HTML, Excel or PDF.
Limits and cautions
- The broker’s statement is the official record; a personal copy never overrides it.
- Statement layouts and terms differ between brokers; check the one you receive.
- This is not accounting, tax or legal advice, and the example numbers are hypothetical.
Frequently asked questions
Why does my MT5 history not match my broker statement?
Which one is correct if they differ?
How small a difference is normal?
Do open trades count in the statement?
Can the journal app reconcile with my statement?
Related guides
- A local trading journal for MT5
- P&L calendar for MT5
- Trade notes, ratings and screenshots
- Trading progress and goals
- Back up your journal and move it to a new PC
- An offline trading journal for Windows
- How to set monthly trading goals
- Import your whole MT5 history
- How to tag trades
- Trade screenshots for your journal
- All trading journal comparisons
Keep a clean copy of your closed trades: free for 7 days
Free for 7 days, no card required. After that, a one-time $19.99 purchase. No subscription. Also on the Microsoft Store.
One-time $19.99, no monthly fee · your MT5 login never leaves your PC · trades go into your own journal on your PC, not through our servers.
Start free 7-day trial