Risk to reward from your MT5 trade history: planned versus realised

What the history can and cannot tell you about your real ratio, and how to measure it.

Risk to reward is one of the most quoted ideas in trading, and one of the least checked. Traders plan a stop and a target before they enter, then rarely measure what the closed trades actually delivered. MetaTrader 5 gives you part of what you need and withholds the rest. This page explains what the history can and cannot tell you about realised risk to reward, how to work around the gaps, and how to read the result next to your win rate so the ratio does not mislead you.

Planned versus realised

Planned risk to reward is the distance to your target divided by the distance to your stop at the moment you enter. Realised risk to reward is what really happened: the average winning trade divided by the average losing trade, measured in money. The two often differ, because trades are closed early, stops are moved and targets are not always reached. Planned ratio describes your intention. Realised ratio describes your behaviour. The second is the one your account balance feels.

What MT5 history stores about stops and targets

A position in the history can show a Stop Loss and a Take Profit price. Those are the levels the position held when it closed, which is not necessarily what you set when you opened it. If you moved the stop to break even or trailed it, the history shows the final level. That makes the original planned risk impossible to recover from the history alone; see modifying stop loss and take profit in history and break-even stops in trade history. A trade that never had a stop shows an empty field, so it cannot be given a planned ratio at all.

QuestionCan history answer it?Where to look
What was my average winner and loser in money?YesNet result per closed position
What stop did I plan at entry?Not reliablyYour own note or screenshot at entry
Did I move the stop?Not directlyOrder modifications are not a clean record
Did I hit my target?SometimesThe comment and close price; see take profit versus manual close
How much did I risk in money?Only if you record itYour journal field or a calculation from lot size and stop

Realised ratio: the simple calculation

Take your closed positions for a period and compute the net result of each. Average the winners, average the losers as a positive number, and divide the first by the second. Pair it with the win rate, because the two travel together: a modest ratio can be perfectly healthy with a high win rate, and a large ratio can still lose money with a low one. The break-even relationship is simple. If the realised ratio is R, you need to win a bit more than one trade in (1 + R) to avoid losing money before costs. With a ratio of 2 that is a little over a third of trades; with a ratio of 0.5 it is two thirds. Compare this with your actual win rate in win rate, profit factor and expectancy and expected payoff.

A worked example (hypothetical)

Suppose a month of twenty closed positions, with invented numbers: eight winners averaging +22.00, twelve losers averaging -11.00.

ItemValue
Winners8 (40%)
Average winner+22.00
Average loser-11.00
Realised ratio2.0
Break-even win rate at that ratioabout 33%
Net before costs+44.00 (176.00 minus 132.00)

At a ratio of 2.0 the trader needs to win about one trade in three to break even before costs, and they won 40 percent, so the month was positive. Now change the story slightly. If three of the eight winners had been closed early at half their intended size, the average winner would drop, the ratio would fall to about 1.5, the break-even win rate would rise to 40 percent, and the same win rate would produce nothing. That is the practical value of measuring: it shows how early exits and moved stops quietly change the arithmetic, a point developed in take profit hit or manual close.

Recording the plan yourself

Because history cannot tell you what you intended, record it. At entry, note the planned stop distance, the planned target distance and, if you use one, the money at risk. A note field or a tag is enough. Later you can compare planned with realised for each trade, which exposes habits such as always closing early or always widening a stop. Screenshots help, since the picture at entry is a record nobody can edit afterwards; see screenshots for your journal. For the price-distance part, points, pips and pipettes keeps units straight.

Costs and the ratio

Spread, commission and swap all push the effective ratio down, and they hit small targets harder than large ones. A target that is only a few times the typical cost leaves very little after costs. Always compute the ratio on net results, not on gross profit, and see trading costs in your history for where each cost appears.

AI Trading Journal is a Windows app for MetaTrader 5 only. It reads closed trades from the terminal on your PC, adds new ones every 5 minutes, and keeps the journal in a file in your Documents folder. Each journal entry has fields for setup, emotion, whether you followed your plan, a rating and notes, so you can write the planned stop and target in the notes. The app does not capture intended prices automatically, and it does not capture charts on its own. The app is read-only: it never places, modifies or closes a trade, and it gives no trading advice. The 7-day trial needs no card, and the full version is $19.99 once, with no subscription.

Limits

Frequently asked questions

Does MT5 history show my original stop loss?
It shows the stop held at the time of closing. If you moved it, the original is not recoverable from history alone.
How do I calculate realised risk to reward?
Divide the average winning trade by the average losing trade, using net results in money.
What win rate do I need for a given ratio?
Break-even win rate is roughly 1 divided by (1 plus the ratio), before costs. A ratio of 2 needs about one win in three.
Why is my realised ratio lower than planned?
Common reasons are early exits, moved stops and costs. Compare planned with realised for each trade to see which.
Can the journal app record planned risk?
You can write it in the notes field of each entry; the app does not capture intended prices automatically.

Related guides

Journal your plan and result: free for 7 days

Free for 7 days, no card required. After that, a one-time $19.99 purchase. No subscription. Also on the Microsoft Store.

One-time $19.99, no monthly fee · your MT5 login never leaves your PC · trades go into your own journal on your PC, not through our servers.

Start free 7-day trial