MT5 first trade of the day: do your results change as the day goes on?

Rank each day's trades in order and see whether your own history shows a pattern, without over-reading a small sample.

Some traders feel sharpest on the first trade of the session and sloppiest by the fifth. Others find the opposite: the first trade is a warm-up and the later ones are better. Feelings are unreliable here, but your closed-trade history can answer the question with plain counting. This page shows how to rank each day's trades in order, compare the first trade with the rest, and read the result without drawing conclusions from a handful of days.

What you are measuring

The idea is simple: for every trading day, number the closed positions in the order they were opened, then compare results by that number. The first trade of the day is number one, the second is number two, and so on. You are not trying to prove that early trades are better or worse in general. You are checking whether your own history shows a pattern worth a closer look, such as a first trade that is consistently the weakest or a third trade onwards that keeps giving back what the morning earned.

Prepare the data

Work from positions, one row per trade, not from deals. Each position produces at least two deals, so counting deals would number your entries and exits separately and spoil the ranking; the difference is explained in positions versus deals. Copy the closed positions for the period you want using the steps in sorting, filtering and copying history rows and choose a period long enough to matter, which you can set as described in history period and custom date range. Menu wording varies by build, so check your own terminal.

Two choices need a rule. First, rank by open time rather than close time, because the decision you want to study is the decision to enter. Second, the day boundary follows your broker's server clock, so a trade you took late in the evening at home might belong to tomorrow on the server; see server time explained and open time versus close time before you decide a trade is on the wrong day.

Build the comparison

In a spreadsheet add a date helper column from the open time, then a rank column that counts how many trades on the same date opened at or before this one. A COUNTIFS formula on the date and the open time does this. Then add a bucket column with four labels: first, second, third, and fourth or later. Pivot by bucket and show these measures.

MeasureHow to calculateWhat it tells you
TradesCount in the bucketWhether the bucket is large enough to read at all
Net resultProfit plus swap plus commission, summedThe bottom line for that position in the day
Average per tradeNet result divided by tradesLets small and large buckets compare
Win rateWinners divided by tradesContext only, because it ignores size
Largest lossWorst net result in the bucketShows whether one trade dominates the bucket

A worked example (hypothetical)

The numbers below are invented to show how to read the table. They are not from a real account and are not a benchmark for anyone.

Trade of the dayTradesNet resultAverageWin rateLargest loss
First40+36.00+0.9050%-21.00
Second28+42.00+1.5054%-18.00
Third17-9.00-0.5341%-25.00
Fourth or later12-58.00-4.8333%-40.00

Reading it: the first two buckets are modestly positive, the third is flat and the fourth-or-later bucket is clearly negative with the biggest single loss. There are only twelve trades in that last bucket, so this is a prompt to look, not a verdict. The useful next step is to open those twelve trades and read your notes. Were they revenge entries after a loss, trades outside your plan, or simply a different market late in the day? A pattern like this often lines up with busy days costing more than quiet ones and with what you do after a run of losses.

Cross-checks that keep you honest

What to do with the finding

Treat the result as a question for your next review, not a rule. If your later trades look weaker, the question is why you take them: a plan that allows only certain setups, a daily trade limit you set in advance, or a short break after a loss are common process ideas, but whether any of them suits you is your decision, and none of this is advice. If the first trade looks weakest, the question might be whether you rush the open or wait for the setup you wrote down. Write the question and your own answer in the journal entry notes so the next month's data can confirm or contradict it. A habit of this kind is built into the monthly trading performance report.

AI Trading Journal is a Windows app for MetaTrader 5 only. It reads closed trades from the terminal on your PC, adds new ones every 5 minutes, and keeps the journal in a file in your Documents folder. Each closed position is one journal entry with a setup, emotion, plan-followed flag, rating, tags and notes, so you can mark the first trade of the day or a late trade with a tag and filter by it later, and Export Report to Excel gives you the Trades tab to rank by time yourself. The app is read-only: it never places, modifies or closes a trade, and it gives no trading advice. The 7-day trial needs no card, and the full version is $19.99 once, with no subscription.

Limits

Frequently asked questions

How do I find the first trade of each day in MT5?
Sort closed positions by open time, then rank them within each server-clock date. A spreadsheet COUNTIFS formula on the date and open time gives the rank.
Should I rank by open time or close time?
Open time, because you are studying the decision to enter. Be consistent whichever you pick.
How many trades do I need before this means anything?
More than a handful per bucket. With very few trades the averages are mostly noise, so treat early results as questions, not conclusions.
Why does a trade show on a different day than my local date?
History uses the broker's server clock, which can be a few hours ahead of or behind your local time.
Can the journal app flag first trades for me?
You can add a tag to an entry and filter by it. The Excel export includes the trade list so you can rank by time in a spreadsheet.

Related guides

Review your trades by order: free for 7 days

Free for 7 days, no card required. After that, a one-time $19.99 purchase. No subscription. Also on the Microsoft Store.

One-time $19.99, no monthly fee · your MT5 login never leaves your PC · trades go into your own journal on your PC, not through our servers.

Start free 7-day trial